New favorite cookie alert!
This Cookies & Cups recipe for Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese Marshmallow Cookies is delicious. Now I know, those cookies sound intense and probably time consuming. Au contraire my friends. The chocolate chip cookie itself is super simple, and if your house is like mine you already have the ingredients you need.
I had been wanting to use cornstarch in a cookie recipe for a while since I’ve read countless times about the awesome chewiness that happens when baking with cornstarch. I also wanted to make something sort of decadent since I hadn’t baked anything in a while. This cookie fit the bill. I used mini semi-sweet chips for these cookies and I really loved the results. I had forgotten how fun and tasty the extra small pieces of chocolate are, plus they seemed to be more evenly distributed throughout the batter. See? Look at that glorious batter. YUM.
I didn’t have parchment paper even though I could have sworn we had some at home… Apparently not. So instead of putting wax paper underneath my cookies and risking wax transfer I used foil, that old standby. I also used a cookie scoop to form these fat balls of dough because the recipe said large scoops and I really wanted chewy cookies. Oven ready!
I followed the recipe’s instructions for the marshmallows and cooking time, only adding about a minute of time since my oven is temperamental. Then, once all the cookies were cooling I could use the mixing bowl to make the cream cheese frosting. Now of course, I didn’t have very much cream cheese left in the container. What can I say, I like bagels. But I figured I could make due with what I had, cutting it a little with butter and milk, plus not wanting to make as much frosting anyway. The results were still super tasty, just enough frosting to drizzle over each cookie.
The sweetness of the frosting/glaze + the marshmallows cut the the less sweet chocolate chips which I knew would sell them to my family. Later on once they completely cooled, I liked these cookies better re-heated slightly to melt the chocolate up making them more ooey-gooey (my favorite!). I made them a week ago, and they kept for about 5 days in a reusable container. Reheating them is definitely the trick though, because they tasted soooo much better warm.
Overall, I would definitely make these again, perhaps even just the cookie recipe without all the trappings. I was really happy with how thick the cookies stayed while still cooking through, because I prefer chewy cookies over thin crunchy ones. What’s not to love about a warm, hefty chocolate chip cookie?Again, new fave! And of course, all credit to Shelly over at Cookies & Cups.